Buffalo nickels are more than just vintage coins—they’re small pieces of American history that fascinate collectors and investors alike.
Some of these iconic nickels have soared in value, turning ordinary pocket change into significant financial windfalls.
Their worth depends on factors such as rarity, minting errors, and historical significance, making them highly desirable in the numismatic market.
With values reaching into the thousands, these coins highlight the potential rewards of collecting.
Here are twelve Buffalo nickels that have dramatically increased in value, proving that even small coins can lead to substantial opportunities.
1937-D Buffalo Nickel (Three-Legged Variety)
The 1937-D “Three-Legged Buffalo” is one of the most famous error coins in numismatic history. This unique mistake occurred due to excessive die polishing at the Denver Mint, creating a coin that remains a top target for collectors.
According to the NGC Price Guide (as of March 2025), a circulated 1937-D Buffalo Nickel is valued between $350 and $1,950.
Pristine, uncirculated examples fetch even higher prices, with top specimens selling for as much as $110,000. Its rarity and distinct error make it a must-have for serious collectors.
1936 Buffalo Nickel (Double Die Obverse)
The 1936 Buffalo Nickel with a Double Die Obverse is highly sought after due to its unique design flaw. The doubling effect, most noticeable on the date and parts of the Native American profile, adds to its appeal.
Minted in Philadelphia, this rare production error highlights the intricacies of early 20th-century coin-making.
A well-preserved example graded MS68 has reached a record auction price of $10,575, with values continuing to rise for coins in exceptional condition.
1913-S Type 2 Buffalo Nickel
The introduction of the Type 2 reverse design in 1913 led to a limited number of coins being minted in San Francisco.
This version features a raised ground beneath the buffalo, distinguishing it from the earlier Type 1 design.
High-grade examples, particularly those graded MS-65, are scarce and have commanded prices exceeding $60,000 at auction.
The design change and historical significance make this coin a prized addition to any collection.
1926-S Buffalo Nickel
With a mintage of just 970,000, the 1926-S Buffalo Nickel is the lowest-minted regular-issue coin in the series. Its rarity makes it a highly coveted piece among collectors.
Although it lacks major errors, its limited availability significantly boosts its value. Depending on the condition, prices range from $15 to $4,400. Uncirculated examples graded MS-65 have fetched up to $135,000, reinforcing their desirability.
1918-D Buffalo Nickel (8 Over 7)
A major overdate error, the 1918-D “8 Over 7” was created when a 1917 die was repurposed for 1918 production. The overlapping numerals make it one of the most recognized errors in the Buffalo Nickel series.
Collectors eagerly seek this coin, with well-preserved specimens selling for over $350,000 at auctions. Its rarity and historical significance cement its place as a cornerstone of numismatic collecting.
1935 Buffalo Nickel (Double Die Reverse)
The 1935 Buffalo Nickel features a “Double Die Reverse,” with noticeable doubling in inscriptions like “Five Cents” and “E Pluribus Unum.” This error significantly enhances its value.
High-grade examples can fetch thousands of dollars, making it an exceptional piece in the Buffalo Nickel series. Its uniqueness and rarity ensure its continued demand among collectors.
1914-D Buffalo Nickel
The 1914-D Buffalo Nickel holds significant value, with USA Coin Book estimating an average condition coin at $151. Uncirculated (MS+) examples range between $572 and $652 or more.
A graded MS-65 specimen can command over $20,000. Coins from this era, especially well-preserved ones, are in high demand due to their historical and numismatic significance.
1924-S Buffalo Nickel
Struck at the San Francisco Mint, the 1924-S Buffalo Nickel had a limited mintage of 1,437,000, increasing its desirability among collectors.
Uncirculated specimens are particularly valuable, with gem-grade examples attracting significant interest. This coin remains a standout addition to any numismatic collection.
1913-S Type 1 Buffalo Nickel
The NGC Price Guide lists the 1913-S Type 1 Buffalo Nickel’s value in circulated grades between $30 and $125, with uncirculated specimens fetching much higher amounts.
Pristine examples have sold for up to $15,000. The coin’s historical and artistic significance enhances its desirability among collectors.
1937-S Buffalo Nickel
Produced at the San Francisco Mint, the 1937-S Buffalo Nickel is relatively common in circulated conditions, with values ranging from $0.50 to $20 according to the NGC Price Guide (March 2025).
However, uncirculated examples in perfect condition are much more valuable, with top-tier specimens selling for up to $22,500. This stark difference in price highlights the demand for well-preserved examples.
1921-S Buffalo Nickel
The 1921-S Buffalo Nickel is a valuable coin, with circulated examples priced between $50 and $2,050 (March 2025 NGC Price Guide).
Uncirculated specimens have reached up to $22,000 at auction. Its limited availability and historical significance make it a sought-after coin among numismatists and investors.
1934 Buffalo Nickel
The 1934 Buffalo Nickel is admired for its design and historical relevance. While circulated versions are widely available, uncirculated examples are much rarer.
Among Philadelphia Mint issues from the 1930s, this coin stands out due to its scarcity in high grades. It remains a favorite among collectors for its aesthetic appeal and numismatic importance.
Disclaimer- Our team has thoroughly fact-checked this article to ensure its accuracy and maintain its credibility. We are committed to providing honest and reliable content for our readers.